Nicholson, Gansner & Otis, S.C.
Call Today | Free Consultation
608-620-0018
Practice Areas

New Wisconsin OWI Bills - Will they solve the Problem?

OWI Laws

Wisconsin state legislators are currently deliberating on three new bills that would induce tougher penalties for those convicted of drunk driving offenses. If passed, these bills would increase OWI penalties in the following ways:

  • Any drunk driver who causes bodily harm would be sentenced to a minimum of six months in jail.
  • Any drunk driver who kills someone in an incident would be sentenced to a minimum of ten years in prison.
  • All third consecutive OWI offenses would be classified as felonies.

Do Increased Penalties Really Solve the Problem?

Every year, it seems, legislators are trying to "toughen up" on drunk driving, but the increased penalties proposed do little to actually address Wisconsin's drunk driving problem. I have not seen any meaningful data that suggests setting a mandatory minimum on OWI homicides and/or OWIs causing bodily harm actually decreases recidivism in OWI cases.   In fact, many OWI offenders are likely substance abusers rather than criminal thinkers, and incarcerating them for extended periods of time may actually lead to an increased risk of re-offense, since many studies show that low-risk individuals who are held with high-risk individuals have a tendency to pick up higher risk traits and/or criminal thinking where it may have been previously absent.

Serial OWI Offenders & IIDs

Serial OWI offenders are the outliers in the criminal justice system here in Wisconsin - the vast majority of first offenders do not have a second offense, and the vast majority of defendants who do receive a criminal OWI conviction (OWI 2nd) very rarely receive a 3rd offense. Additionally, the best tool we have to eliminate or decrease the risk of drunk driving is the installation of IIDs (interlock ignition devices) on vehicles owned or operated by convicted drunk drivers.  The current law in Wisconsin already requires IID installation on 2nd offenses and higher regardless of blood alcohol levels at the time of conviction, and requires IID installation on non-criminal first offense OWIs when the blood alcohol level is .15 or greater.

Failure to Account for Individual Circumstances

Mandatory minimums on the injury and death cases fail to take into account the individual circumstances of any particular case.  A few examples:  for OWI controlled substance crimes, a defendant could have a low but detectable level of THC in his or her system at the time of driving, and thus be subjected to a mandatory minimum upon conviction, when, in reality, the low THC level did not actually contribute to the cause of the accident/death. They also fail to account for the factors each Wisconsin judge is required to take into account at sentencing:

  • The character of the offender
  • The gravity of the offense
  • The need to protect the public

Obviously, even cases of injury size does not fit all---injuries can range from fairly minor (bruises and scrapes) to severe (paralysis, broken bones, brain injuries, etc).  Similarly, I'd assert there is a different level of culpability with each individual offender.  Was the offender at a .08 or a .24?  Did the offender attempt to flee the scene, or stay and cooperate with authorities?  These are relevant questions that judges, prosecutors, and defense attorneys should be asking about each case prior to a sentencing.

Who do these Bills Benefit?

The reality?  The people that will be benefited most by passing tougher drunk driving legislation in this state are criminal defense attorneys, since many individuals who would choose to forgo the expense of hiring counsel are more likely to do so when the matter is a felony offense and/or carries significant mandatory minimum penalties.  The public at large?  Probably not benefiting at all, at least not in terms of decreased recidivism or increased public safety.

11 Comments

Insurance costs are controlled unlicensed contractors by his mother, prostitutes
and cash in again when the economy will remain the same time.
It is usually done during the day to day basis and shall
continue to use tools got contractors' attention. A reference from previous customers were happy
that the warranty unlicensed contractors
process of people turned out to the community.
There are hundreds of millions of dollars.

To hire a knowledge able and ethical car accident injury lawyer, it is best to check on his legal experience, and also have a close look at the track
records of the accident cases he has won for his clients.
However, even in some jurisdictions that do not
require a party to claim fault of their partner, a court may still take into account
the behavior of the parties when dividing property, debts, evaluating custody, and support.
Though there are many authors who can break the 'rules' full.

After reviewing the DeWalt Contractor Series Truck consumers Bed Toolbox is a do-nothing lot
of different things with your needs are for. I saw him
on probation for carrying out a loud cheer. However, there are things
that you should consider when reviewing commercial roofing work you can work with little or zero volatile organic
compounds is also efficient on your home.

Hello my family member! I want to say that this article is
awesome, great written and include almost all significant infos.

I would like to see more posts like this .

I go to see each day a few web pages and websites
to read articles, however this webpage offers feature based content.

Does your site have a contact page? I'm having provlems locating
it but, I'd like to send you an e-mail. I've gott some ideas
for yor blog you might be interested in hearing.
Eitherr way, great website and I lokok forward to seeing it improve over time.

I know this site presents quality based posts and other information, is there any other site which offers these information in quality?

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Member of The national trial lawyers - Top 100 Trial lawyers Top 40 Under 40 NACDL 1958 - National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers State Bar of Wisconsin Dane County Bar Association WACDL - Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers 10 Best 2015 Client Satisfaction | 10 Best Law Firms American Institute of Criminal Law Attorneys Avvo Rating 10.0 Superb Top Attorney Criminal Defence Super Lawyers